Alright, fellow tapeheads, let's rewind to a time when Christmas movies weren't always filled with twinkly lights and heartwarming lessons. Sometimes, they involved disastrous pastries, accidental shootings, and a suicide hotline staffed by the most hilariously inept people imaginable. If your festive cheer needs a serious dose of Gallic cynicism and pitch-black slapstick, then you absolutely need to dig out (or track down) a copy of 1982’s magnificent French train wreck, Le Père Noël est une ordure, often known to English speakers, quite aptly, as Santa Claus Is a Stinker.
This isn't your typical heartwarming holiday fare; it's more like holiday heartburn, and it’s glorious. Forget snowy villages and reindeer – our setting is the cramped, increasingly chaotic office of "SOS Détresse Amitié," a Parisian telephone helpline on Christmas Eve. Staffing the phones are the uptight Thérèse (Anémone, unforgettable) and the well-meaning but perpetually flustered Pierre Mortez (Thierry Lhermitte). Their already stressful night spirals completely out of control with the arrival of characters like the perpetually pregnant and perpetually homeless Zézette (Marie-Anne Chazel) and her abusive, Santa-suit-wearing boyfriend Félix (Gérard Jugnot). And that's just the beginning of the madness.
Meet the Troupe
What makes Le Père Noël est une ordure truly spark is that it’s a product of the legendary French comedy troupe Le Splendid. Think of them as a Gallic Monty Python, a tight-knit group who wrote and performed together, honing their anarchic energy on stage before bringing it to the screen. The core writers and stars – Josiane Balasko (who plays the frumpy radio host Madame Musquin), Marie-Anne Chazel, Christian Clavier (as the hilariously awkward transvestite Katia), Gérard Jugnot, and Thierry Lhermitte – had already adapted their stage play Amours, coquillages et crustacés into the hit film Les Bronzés (French Fried Vacation) a few years earlier. This film, also based on one of their plays, cemented their status. Their chemistry is electric; they bounce off each other with the timing and familiarity only years of collaboration can forge. Anémone, while not part of the original stage play lineup, is absolutely essential here, her repressed hysteria as Thérèse providing a perfect counterpoint to the escalating chaos.
Comedy Darker Than Burnt Fruitcake
Let's be clear: the humour here is dark. We're talking jokes about suicide attempts, domestic violence, poverty, and general human awfulness, all delivered with a rapid-fire, almost farcical energy. Director Jean-Marie Poiré, who would later give us the massive international hit Les Visiteurs (1993) starring Clavier, keeps the pace frantic, maximizing the claustrophobia of the single main set. It feels like a pressure cooker of bad decisions and social awkwardness about to explode. Remember those bizarre, hand-knitted jumpers Thérèse makes? Or the infamous "doubitchous de Sofia," those truly repulsive-looking Balkan pastries Pierre offers? These visual gags are just part of the film's unique, grubby charm. That pastry, by the way, became so iconic in France that recipes (usually far more palatable than the prop likely was) still circulate online!
The film brilliantly captures a certain kind of weary, end-of-year desperation, cranked up to eleven. It’s the antithesis of Capra-corn sentimentality. Finding this on a grainy VHS tape back in the day, perhaps with wonky subtitles, felt like discovering a secret handshake into a world of comedy that wasn't afraid to be mean, messy, and utterly un-PC by today's standards. It was bracing! There’s a rawness here, a sense of performers pushing boundaries, that felt incredibly fresh. Was it shocking back then? Absolutely. The title alone caused a stir, and its refusal to offer easy resolutions or likeable characters made it stand out.
Practical Panic
While not an action film, the physical comedy is intense and relies entirely on the performers' commitment and timing – pure practical mayhem. When things inevitably go wrong (and oh boy, do they go wrong), the chaos feels tangible. The cramped apartment set becomes a character itself, a stage for escalating farce where bodies might literally end up needing disposal. There's no CGI gloss here, just performers throwing themselves into ludicrous situations with utter conviction. You feel the rising panic in Pierre's eyes, the barely contained fury in Félix’s gestures. It’s the kind of controlled chaos that live theatre experience brings to the screen. It's fascinating to think this entire disasterpiece reportedly cost under $1 million to make back in '82 – a testament to the power of sharp writing and a killer ensemble cast.
Still Hilariously Offensive?
Watching Le Père Noël est une ordure today is a fascinating experience. The humour is definitely of its time, occasionally wince-inducing, but overwhelmingly hilarious if you appreciate black comedy. Its influence on French comedy is undeniable, and it remains a perennial, if perverse, holiday viewing tradition in France. It’s a snapshot of a certain fearless comedic spirit that feels rare now. The sheer density of quotable lines ("C'est c'la, oui...") and unforgettable moments makes it endlessly rewatchable. I distinctly remember the first time seeing Félix’s aggressive breakdown while stuck in the elevator – comedy gold forged from pure desperation.
---
Rating: 9/10
Justification: This score reflects the film's brilliance as a piece of ensemble comedy, its audacious dark humour, and its enduring cult status. It's expertly written and performed by the legendary Le Splendid troupe at the height of their powers. While some elements haven't aged perfectly, its overall impact and comedic genius remain undeniable. It loses a point perhaps only for niche appeal outside of France and humour that might be too dark for some.
Final Thought: Forget the milk and cookies; leave out a shot of cheap brandy and some questionable pastries for this Santa. Le Père Noël est une ordure is the gloriously grubby, hysterically funny antidote to festive schmaltz – a true VHS-era treasure for those who like their comedy black as coal.